The following is a full listing of the cast for the episode "Every Night Is Another Story".
- Chad Michael Murray as Lucas Scott
- James Lafferty as Nathan Scott
- Hilarie Burton as Peyton Sawyer
- Bethany Joy Lenz as Haley James
- Paul Johansson as Dan Scott
- Sophia Bush as Brooke Davis
- Barry Corbin as Whitey Durham
- Craig Sheffer as Keith Scott
- Moira Kelly as Karen Roe
- Sam Horrigan as Thing
- Dan Becker as Thing #2
- Dave Power as Thing #3
- Barbara Alyn Woods as Deb Scott
- Lee Norris as Mouth McFadden
- Brett Claywell as Tim Smith
- B.J. Britt as Referee
- Sam Robison as Trainer
- Robert C. Treveiler as Entrepreneur
- Jeff Wicker as M.C.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.