How Can You Be Sure?/Cast
Episode By Cast
The Leaving Song/Cast

Emmanuelle Vaugier and Sophia Bush as Nicki and Brooke Davis in "What Is and What Should Never Be".

The following is a full listing of the cast for the episode "What Is and What Should Never Be".



Guest Starring

  • Blake Bashoff as Gary Matheson
  • Richard Bryant as Stoner #1
  • Drake Johnson as Party Kid
  • Bobby Tyson as Cop
  • Adam Heffernan as College Guy
  • Dean James as Bartender
  • Dan Cox as Customer
  • Jennifer Owens as Cop #2
  • Leigh Jones as Popular Girl
  • Ryan Kowalske as Stoner #2
  • Mike Pniewski as Mr. Carlson

Also Starring

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.